#1Fenelton
Geibel's Butcher Shop
★ 4.9 on Google (11 reviews) · 144 Geibel Rd, Fenelton, PA 16034
–Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off✓Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Best Deer Processors in Fenelton, PA
The 15 best-rated deer processors in and around Fenelton, Butler County: 1 in Fenelton itself and the rest within about 20 miles. Shops in town come first, then each group is ranked by Google rating weighted by review count, state program participation and distance.
How we rank: a Google rating with fewer reviews counts for less than one with many; shops on the 2026 state program lists, HSH partners and CWD cooperators get a small boost; farther shops get a small penalty per mile. Shops in town are listed ahead of nearby ones. Nobody pays for placement. Details
15ranked
processors
processors
FILTER:
Welters Meat Shop
★ 5.0 on Google (64 reviews) · 170 Welter Rd., Butler, PA 16002
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
DeliMeat packer
PRICINGCall for rates
Gutherie Deer Processing
★ 5.0 on Google (11 reviews) · 168 Gutherie Road, Cowansville, PA 16218
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Ciafre's Deer Processing
★ 4.8 on Google (45 reviews) · 1215 Pittsburgh Rd., Valencia, PA 16059
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest✓PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off✓Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Schnur's Country Market
★ 4.9 on Google (115 reviews) · 252 Bonniebrook Rd, Butler, PA 16002
–Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off✓Website or Facebook
Boneless cutsCustom cuts / cut & wrapGround venison / burgerJerkyBologna / Lebanon bologna
PRICINGCall for rates
Bims Boloney
★ 4.8 on Google (24 reviews) · 145 Morris Road, Petrolia, PA 16050
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
McKruit's Custom Meat Cutting
★ 4.7 on Google (41 reviews) · 1011 Bear Creek Road, Cabot, PA 16023
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off✓Website or Facebook
Custom cuts / cut & wrapGround venison / burgerJerkyFresh sausageSmoked products
PRICINGCall for rates
Myers Meat Shop
★ 5.0 on Google (1 review) · 749 Butler Rd., Kittanning, PA 16201
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
OBS Custom Meat Processing
★ 4.5 on Google (8 reviews) · 804 Foxburg Rd., Parker, PA 16373
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off✓Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
J&J Smokehouse
★ 4.5 on Google (34 reviews) · 122 Rosston Cir, Ford City, PA 16226
–Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
CatererFood producer
PRICINGCall for rates
Paul Pollick's Whitetail Deer Lures
★ 4.6 on Google (14 reviews) · 4940 Garvers Ferry Rd, New Kensington, PA 15068
–Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off✓Website or Facebook
Bear processingElk processingBeef / pork custom butcheringRetail meat counterCWD testing / DMA deer accepted
PRICINGCall for rates
Toy's Deer Processing
★ 4.2 on Google (34 reviews) · 1988 State Route 66, Ford City, PA 16226
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest✓PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Huff's Custom Meats
No Google reviews yet · 650 Dick Rd., Butler, PA 16001
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Bob's Deer Processing
No Google reviews yet · 215 Ragan Rd, Prospect, PA 16052
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Graham's Custom Butchering
No Google reviews yet · 12876 State Rt. 422, Kittanning, PA 16201
✓Hunters Sharing the Harvest–PGC CWD cooperating processor–After-hours drop-off–Website or Facebook
PRICINGCall for rates
Getting a deer processed near Fenelton
There is 1 processor in Fenelton itself, plus 14 shops a short drive away. The nearby shops are in Butler (2 mi), Cowansville (8 mi), Cabot (9 mi) and Petrolia (10 mi). Geibel's Butcher Shop leads the ranking with a 4.9 average from 11 Google reviews. Schnur's Country Market has the most reviews (115, averaging 4.9).
To donate venison through Hunters Sharing the Harvest, use Welters Meat Shop, Gutherie Deer Processing, Ciafre's Deer Processing and 8 more. Ciafre's Deer Processing and Toy's Deer Processing are on the Game Commission's CWD cooperating processor list, approved for proper disposal of high-risk parts. No shop here advertises after-hours drop-off, so plan to arrive during business hours or keep the deer cold overnight.
If you want more than steaks and burger, the shops here list jerky (2 shops), fresh sausage (2 shops), smoked products (2 shops) and bologna. Beyond deer, you can bring bear (Paul Pollick's Whitetail Deer Lures) and elk (Paul Pollick's Whitetail Deer Lures). None of these processors list prices online; most quote a flat base rate plus extras for sausage, sticks and caping.
Fenelton is in Butler County, in the PGC Northwest Region. Region at a glance: Allegheny National Forest country, from Erie and Warren south through Venango, Mercer and Clarion. Other Butler County towns with listed processors: Butler, Cabot, Parker, Petrolia, Prospect and 2 more. Rifle season fills coolers fast on opening weekend, so call before you head out.
More Butler County cities
Drop-off checklist
- Tag it right away. Tag the deer immediately after harvest and before you move it. The tag goes on the ear and stays there until the deer is processed.
- Field dress and cool fast. Remove entrails, drain the cavity and get the deer cold. In warm weather, pack the cavity with bagged ice.
- High-risk parts go in the trash. New for 2026-27: you can move a deer anywhere, but once it leaves the kill site the head, backbone and spleen must go out with commercial trash. A processor handles that for you.
- Report within 10 days. Online, by phone at 1-800-838-4431, or with the digest report card.
Donate venison
Hunters Sharing the Harvest
Drop a legally harvested deer at a participating processor and the venison goes to Pennsylvania food banks. Program sponsors usually cover the processing; confirm with the shop.
Find HSH processors →